1843 Seated Liberty Dime Value Guide (P, O & Proof Issues)
The 1843 Seated Liberty Dime ranges from $17 for circulated Philadelphia issues to $195,000+ for rare Mint State 1843-O examples. Proof specimens command $12,500-$45,000.
The 1843 Seated Liberty Dime is worth $17 to $195,000 depending on mint mark and condition.
- 1843 Philadelphia (P): $17 (G-4) to $8,250 (MS-66)
- 1843-O New Orleans: $90 (AG-3) to $195,000+ (MS-62)
- 1843 Proof: $12,500 (PR-63) to $45,000 (PR-66)
The 1843-O is a celebrated key date with only 150,000 minted and fewer than 200 survivors, while the Philadelphia issue with 1,370,000 minted serves as an accessible type coin.
What's Your 1843 Dime Worth?
Select your coin's mint mark and condition to get a value estimate.
Focus on choosing the right sales channel to maximize your return.
Expected: ()
1843 Seated Liberty Dime: Accessible Type Coin Meets Key Date Rarity
The 1843 Seated Liberty Dime features the Type 3 'With Drapery' design.
The 1843 Seated Liberty Dime represents a study in contrasts within U.S. numismatics. The Philadelphia Mint issue, with a substantial mintage of 1,370,000 pieces, serves as an accessible and popular type coin for collectors seeking examples of the 'With Drapery' design variant. In sharp contrast, the New Orleans issue is a celebrated key date: with only 150,000 coins struck and an estimated 200 survivors, the 1843-O commands premium prices in all grades and reaches six-figure values in Mint State condition. Adding to the year's numismatic significance are extremely rare Proof strikings from Philadelphia, with an estimated original mintage of only 8 to 10 examples.
This guide covers all three issues—business strikes from both mints and Proof specimens—providing detailed market values, grading diagnostics, die varieties, and collecting strategies for the 1843 dime.
How to Identify Your 1843 Seated Liberty Dime
The O mint mark appears on the reverse, centered inside the wreath below the bow.
All 1843 Seated Liberty Dimes belong to the Type 3 'Stars Obverse, With Drapery' design, produced from 1840 through 1853. This type was designed by Christian Gobrecht and Robert Ball Hughes, and is distinguished from earlier variants by the addition of a prominent fold of drapery extending from Liberty's left elbow to her forearm.
Obverse Design
The obverse features Liberty seated on a rock, holding a pole topped with a liberty cap in her left hand and a shield inscribed with 'LIBERTY' in her right hand. Thirteen stars surround the figure, with seven to the left and six to the right. The date '1843' appears below Liberty's feet. The key identifying feature of the Type 3 design is the drapery fold extending from Liberty's left elbow across her forearm—earlier types lack this detail.
Reverse Design
The reverse displays a wreath composed of agricultural elements (corn, wheat, maple, and oak) enclosing the denomination 'ONE DIME.' The legend 'UNITED STATES OF AMERICA' surrounds the wreath. The wreath is tied at the bottom with a bow.
Mint Mark Location
The mint mark location is on the reverse, centered inside the wreath below the bow. The Philadelphia Mint issue bears no mint mark. The New Orleans Mint issue is identified by a small, capital 'O' in this position. Examining this area carefully under good lighting or magnification will reveal whether your coin is the common Philadelphia issue or the rare 1843-O key date.
Distinguishing Business Strikes from Proofs
Proof coins were struck using specially prepared dies and polished planchets, resulting in mirrored fields and frosted design elements. Proof 1843 dimes are extremely rare—only 8 to 10 examples were originally struck—and exhibit razor-sharp details with reflective surfaces that are immediately distinguishable from business strikes when examined under proper lighting.
1843 Seated Liberty Dime Price Guide
The market for 1843 Seated Liberty Dimes is sharply divided based on mint of origin. The Philadelphia issue is readily available in most circulated grades and serves as an affordable type coin, while the New Orleans issue is a major key date commanding substantial premiums at all grade levels. Proof specimens represent the pinnacle of rarity for the year.
1843 (Philadelphia Mint) Business Strike Values
With a generous mintage of 1,370,000 coins, the 1843 Philadelphia issue is one of the most readily available dates in the 'With Drapery' sub-series. It is widely accessible in circulated grades through About Uncirculated. Collectors are most likely to encounter Mint State examples in the MS-63 and MS-64 range, while Gem specimens (MS-65 and higher) are scarce and highly sought after. The market for this coin is liquid and well-established.
| Grade | Value Range |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $17 - $25 |
| VG-8 | $22 - $30 |
| F-12 | $35 - $40 |
| VF-20 | $55 - $60 |
| EF-40 | $100 - $140 |
| AU-50 | $200 - $280 |
| MS-60 | $375 - $440 |
| MS-63 | $800 - $880 |
| MS-65 | $3,300 |
| MS-66 | $7,200 - $8,250 |
Note: An example from the Gardner collection sold for $8,225 in 2014. A February 2023 auction record shows $7,200 for an MS-66 specimen.
1843-O (New Orleans Mint) Business Strike Values
The 1843-O dime is a classic key date within the Seated Liberty series. Its low mintage of 150,000 pieces ensures scarcity in all grades. Survival estimates suggest only about 200 examples exist in any condition, with a mere four known in Mint State. This extreme rarity creates one of the most dramatic value progressions in the series. While circulated examples are expensive, they remain obtainable. However, the transition to Uncirculated grades marks a monumental leap in both rarity and price, creating a 'rarity cliff' that separates this issue into two distinct collecting tiers.
| Grade | Value Range |
|---|---|
| AG-3 | $90 |
| G-4 | $90 - $220 |
| VG-8 | $240 - $312 |
| F-12 | $390 - $890 |
| VF-20 | $881 - $1,320 |
| EF-40 | $1,920 - $2,990 |
| AU-50 | $12,000 |
| AU-58 | $10,692 - $23,500 |
| MS-62 | $141,000 - $195,000 |
Note: A PCGS AG-3 sold for $90 in March 2018. A PCGS F-15 sold for $504 in November 2017. An NGC XF40 sold for $2,520 in July 2019. A PCGS AU-53 sold for $14,950 in June 2010. A PCGS AU-58 sold for $10,692 in August 2015. A PCGS MS-62 (CAC) sold for $141,000 in June 2014. The finest known specimen, graded MS-66, ex-Eliasberg, sold for $29,700 in May 1996; its value today would be substantially higher.
1843 Proof Values
The 1843 Proof Seated Liberty Dime is an object of profound rarity. Struck at the Philadelphia Mint, these coins were produced in minuscule quantities for presentation purposes or inclusion in proof sets distributed to government officials. The exact mintage is unknown, but numismatic scholarship estimates only 8 to 10 pieces were originally struck, with a survival estimate of eight coins across all grades. Only a single specimen is known in Gem condition (PR-65 or higher).
| Grade | Value Range |
|---|---|
| PR-63 | $12,500 - $18,500 |
| PR-64 | $14,100 - $25,000 |
| PR-65 | $22,325 - $35,000 |
| PR-66 | $25,850 - $45,000 |
Note: A PCGS PR-64 sold for $14,100 in January 2013. An auction record of $29,900 was set in February 2008 for a PR-65. A PCGS PR-65 sold for $22,325 in January 2014. The sole finest NGC PR-66 (Ex-Pittman) sold for $25,850 in June 2014.
💡 Melt Value Note
Based on a silver spot price of $48.00 per troy ounce, the intrinsic melt value of an 1843 Seated Liberty Dime (0.0773 troy oz silver content) is approximately $3.71. However, this melt value is purely academic—even the most heavily worn examples command numismatic values several times their silver content. The melt value should never be used as a basis for determining market price.
Grading Your 1843 Seated Liberty Dime
Grade comparison: G-4 (heavy wear), VF-20 (moderate wear), MS-65 (full luster).
Accurate grading is essential for determining the value of your 1843 Seated Liberty Dime. The series presents several challenges, and understanding key diagnostics will help you assess condition properly. Professional third-party grading is strongly recommended for valuable specimens, particularly the 1843-O key date.
Wear first appears on Liberty's head, breast, and knee, plus the wreath high points.
Key Areas to Inspect
On the obverse, examine Liberty's head (particularly the hair above the ear), her right breast, and her left knee—these are the highest points of the design where wear first appears. The word 'LIBERTY' on the shield is a primary determinant for grades in the Good to Fine range; the number of visible letters helps establish the grade level. On the reverse, check the high points of the wreath's leaves and the bow for signs of wear.
Circulated Grades
Good (G-4): Heavy wear with Liberty's outline visible but most details worn smooth. The date is barely visible. On the shield, 'LIBERTY' may be partially or fully worn away. Rim is complete but may merge with the design in places.
Very Good (VG-8): Liberty's outline is clear with some major details visible. At least three letters of 'LIBERTY' are readable. The date is clear. Moderate wear on the high points.
Fine (F-12): All major design elements are visible with moderate wear. 'LIBERTY' is complete and readable. Liberty's hair shows some detail. The wreath on the reverse retains partial leaf definition.
Very Fine (VF-20): Light to moderate wear on the high points. 'LIBERTY' is sharp. Liberty's hair shows good detail with individual strands visible. The wreath leaves show clear definition.
Extremely Fine (EF-40): Light wear confined to the highest points. Nearly full detail in Liberty's hair and gown. The wreath retains most of its fine details. Original luster may be visible in protected areas.
About Uncirculated (AU-50, AU-58): Minimal wear on the highest points only. Most original luster is present, with friction evident on Liberty's head, breast, knee, and the wreath high points.
Mint State Grades
MS-60 to MS-62: No trace of wear, but contact marks, bagmarks, or unattractive toning may be present. Luster may be slightly impaired.
MS-63 to MS-64: Moderate to good eye appeal with fewer contact marks. Original luster is strong. This is the most frequently encountered Mint State grade range for the Philadelphia issue.
MS-65 to MS-66: Gem quality with excellent eye appeal, minimal marks, and strong luster. These grades are scarce for the 1843 Philadelphia issue and extremely rare for the 1843-O.
Strike quality comparison: weak strike (left) shows flat details despite no wear; strong strike (right) shows full definition.
Critical Distinction: Strike Weakness vs. Wear
Seated Liberty Dimes, especially those from the New Orleans Mint, are frequently found with weak strikes. This results in a lack of detail on Liberty's head, the stars, or the lower part of the shield, even on uncirculated examples. A coin with a weak strike is not necessarily a lower grade—a professional grader will assess the remaining luster and evidence of actual friction on the high points to determine whether the flatness is from striking or circulation. Learning to differentiate between strike weakness and circulation wear is essential for accurate grading.
Die Varieties of the 1843 Seated Liberty Dime
Die variety collecting adds an additional dimension to the Seated Liberty Dime series. While numerous minor die marriages exist for the Philadelphia issue, only one variety commands significant collector attention and premium pricing. The New Orleans issue was struck from a single die pair.
The FS-301 variety shows clear doubling on all four date digits, strongest on '184'.
1843 Repunched Date (FS-301, Fortin-102)
This is the most prominent and widely collected variety of the 1843 Philadelphia dime. The FS-301 variety exhibits clear repunching on all four digits of the date. The repunching is evident with low magnification and is often strongest on the '184' digits, where the doubling creates a bold, eye-catching effect. This variety is popular with collectors and is listed in major numismatic references including the Fivaz-Stanton guide and Gerry Fortin's Comprehensive Guide to Liberty Seated Dimes.
The FS-301 variety consistently commands a premium of approximately 25-30% over the common 1843 dime in the same grade. In lower circulated grades (G-VG), the premium ranges from $25-$40 versus $20-$25 for the common date. In higher grades, the premium scales proportionally: MS-60-63 examples range from $550-$1,100 compared to $440-$880 for common 1843 dimes.
1843-O Fortin-101
Extensive research has concluded that the entire mintage of the 1843-O dime was produced using a single obverse and reverse die pair. Therefore, the designation Fortin-101 (or F-101) applies to all known examples of this issue. There are no major collectible die varieties for the 1843-O that command separate premiums—the scarcity and value of this key date derive from its low mintage and survival rate rather than from die characteristics.
Other Philadelphia Varieties
PCGS and Fortin's reference list several other die marriages for the 1843 Philadelphia issue, including F-101, F-101a, F-102a, F-103 (the proof die), F-104, F-105, F-105a, and F-106. These are primarily of interest to die variety specialists studying the complete die usage of the year. With the exception of the F-102 (FS-301 Repunched Date), these varieties do not carry a significant or widely recognized market premium and are generally not distinguished in regular dealer inventories.
Mint Errors on 1843 Seated Liberty Dimes
Genuine mint errors on 19th-century coinage are scarce and highly collectible among specialists. While no major, widely publicized errors are documented for the 1843 dime, several error types are plausible given the minting technology of the era. Values for such errors are highly dependent on the type, severity, and grade of the host coin, and are typically determined on a case-by-case basis at auction.
Die cracks appear as raised lines where the die itself has fractured.
Off-Center Strikes
If a planchet was improperly seated between the dies during striking, a portion of the design would be missing. The value of an off-center strike depends on the degree of misalignment and whether key features (particularly the date and mint mark) remain visible. Minor off-center strikes (5-10%) might add a premium of $75-$150 to a circulated coin. A more dramatic off-center strike (25-50%) with the date and mint mark still visible could be worth several hundred dollars to error specialists.
Die Cracks and Die Clashes
Die cracks appear as raised lines on the coin's surface where the die itself has fractured. Die clashes occur when the obverse and reverse dies strike each other without a planchet in between, transferring a faint impression of each design to the opposing die. Minor examples of either add little to no value. However, a dramatic 'shattered die' with multiple, heavy cracks or a strong, clear clash might add a small premium of $20-$50 to specialists. New Orleans coinage is particularly known for exhibiting die fatigue, making minor die cracks relatively common on 1843-O specimens.
Lamination Errors
Lamination errors occur when a piece of the metal surface flakes off due to an impurity in the planchet alloy. A small lamination peel might not add any value, but a large, retained flap of metal could command a premium of $50-$150 or more, depending on the severity and location of the lamination.
Minor Repunching
Apart from the major FS-301 Repunched Date variety, minor repunching of individual digits may occur on some specimens. Such minor varieties typically appeal only to specialists and carry a minimal premium unless the repunching is particularly dramatic or well-documented in variety references.
Authentication and Counterfeit Detection
Genuine coins have sharp details and consistent surfaces; counterfeits show soft details and porous texture.
Due to the high value of the 1843-O and proof specimens, authentication should be a primary concern for collectors. Counterfeiters have targeted these valuable issues, and several diagnostic characteristics can help identify genuine coins versus fakes.
Weight is a critical first check: a genuine 1843 dime should weigh 2.67 grams. Significant deviations from this weight are a major red flag. Surface characteristics provide another key diagnostic—authentic coins have a consistent, solid surface texture. Counterfeits, particularly cast fakes, often exhibit a porous, pimply, or granular texture that is immediately suspicious under magnification. Detail quality is paramount: on genuine coins, the stars, denticles (teeth) around the rim, and fine lines of Liberty's hair and gown are sharp and well-defined. Counterfeits typically show soft, mushy details where these elements appear blurry or poorly executed.
The date and mint mark deserve special scrutiny. On counterfeits, the numerals of the date and the mint mark are often misshapen, with incorrect fonts or a 'tool-made' appearance that differs from the consistent punch marks used at U.S. Mints. For any 1843-O dime, and certainly for any proof example, authentication and grading by a leading third-party service such as PCGS or NGC is considered mandatory for a safe transaction. The cost of certification is minimal compared to the risk of purchasing a counterfeit of these valuable coins.
Preservation and Storage Best Practices
Proper storage is essential to protect the value and condition of your 1843 Seated Liberty Dime. The 90% silver composition makes these coins susceptible to environmental damage if not properly cared for, and mishandling can cause permanent damage that significantly reduces numismatic value.
For certified coins, the sealed holder (slab) provides excellent long-term protection and should not be removed. Raw coins should be stored in inert, archival-quality materials designed for numismatic preservation. Mylar flips and other holders specifically manufactured for coin storage are recommended—avoid PVC-containing plastics, which can cause chemical damage to silver surfaces over time, resulting in a green, corrosive residue. Store your coins in a cool, dry place with stable temperature and low humidity. This environment helps prevent tarnishing, corrosion, and other environmental damage, while encouraging the slow, natural development of attractive toning that many collectors prize.
Always handle coins by their edges, between the thumb and forefinger. Never touch the obverse or reverse surfaces, as skin oils and residues can cause permanent spots and damage the coin's luster over time. Even a single fingerprint can create lasting discoloration on silver surfaces. When examining coins, work over a soft surface to prevent damage from accidental drops. Never attempt to clean your coins—even gentle cleaning can create hairlines and impair luster, resulting in a 'Details' grade designation that substantially reduces value.
Recent Auction Results
Auction records provide the most reliable indicator of current market values for rare coins, particularly for key dates like the 1843-O and proof specimens where the market is thin and price guide data may lag behind actual transactions. The following notable sales demonstrate the strong demand and price levels for high-grade examples of 1843 Seated Liberty Dimes.
For the Philadelphia business strike issue, an MS-66 specimen sold for $7,200(Heritage, February 2023), while an example from the famous Gardner collection brought $8,225(2014). These top-population coins in Gem condition represent the finest available for the Philadelphia issue and demonstrate strong collector demand at the MS-66 level.
The 1843-O key date has produced dramatic auction results reflecting its extreme rarity in Mint State. A PCGS MS-62 (CAC) specimen realized $141,000(Heritage, June 2014), while the finest known example graded MS-66, from the legendary Eliasberg Collection, sold for $29,700(Bowers and Merena, May 1996)—a price that would be substantially higher in today's market. Even lower-grade specimens command strong prices: a PCGS AU-53 brought $14,950(Heritage, June 2010), while a PCGS AU-58 sold for $10,692(August 2015).
Proof specimens have also established strong auction records. A PCGS PR-65 realized $22,325(Heritage, January 2014), while the finest known NGC PR-66 example from the prestigious Pittman Collection sold for $25,850(Stack's Bowers, June 2014). An earlier record was set in February 2008 when another PR-65 specimen brought $29,900(2008).
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is my 1843 Seated Liberty Dime worth?
The value depends entirely on the mint mark and condition. An 1843 Philadelphia (no mint mark) dime ranges from $17 in Good condition to $8,250 in MS-66. The rare 1843-O (with O mint mark) ranges from $90 in the lowest grades to $195,000+ in Mint State. Proof specimens range from $12,500 to $45,000. Accurate grading is essential—even one grade difference can mean thousands of dollars, especially for the 1843-O.
How do I identify the mint mark on an 1843 dime?
Look at the reverse (back) of the coin, inside the wreath that surrounds 'ONE DIME.' The mint mark, if present, is located directly below the bow that ties the wreath together. Philadelphia coins have no mint mark in this position. If you see a small capital 'O' in this location, you have the rare 1843-O New Orleans issue. Use good lighting or a magnifying glass to examine this area carefully.
Why is the 1843-O dime so valuable?
The 1843-O is a key date due to its combination of low mintage (only 150,000 struck) and extremely low survival rate (approximately 200 examples exist today). Only four Mint State specimens are known. Additionally, the rising price of silver in the years before 1853 caused many silver coins to be melted, disproportionately affecting low-mintage issues like the 1843-O. This rarity creates the dramatic value progression where even circulated examples command strong premiums.
Should I get my 1843 dime professionally graded?
For any 1843-O dime, professional third-party grading by PCGS or NGC is essential—the high value of this key date makes it a target for counterfeits, and certification provides authentication and establishes market value. For Philadelphia mint dimes, certification is recommended if the coin appears to be in AU or better condition, as the cost of grading is easily justified by the price differences between grade levels. Coins showing damage, cleaning, or heavy wear may not be worth the grading fee.
What is the FS-301 Repunched Date variety?
The FS-301 (Fortin-102) is a die variety of the 1843 Philadelphia dime where all four digits of the date show clear doubling due to the date punch being applied to the die multiple times in slightly different positions. The repunching is most prominent on the '184' digits and is visible under low magnification. This variety is popular with collectors and commands a consistent premium of approximately 25-30% over the value of a common 1843 dime in the same grade.
How can I tell if my 1843 dime has been cleaned?
Signs of cleaning include fine, parallel scratches or hairlines across the coin's surfaces (most visible when rotating the coin under a single light source), unnatural or blotchy toning, or a complete lack of toning with a sterile, lifeless luster. 'Whizzing'—mechanical polishing with a rotary tool—creates a deceptively brilliant but unnatural luster and often leaves buildup of metal at the edges of design elements. Cleaned coins will receive a 'Details' grade from certification services and trade at substantial discounts, typically 50-75% less than problem-free coins.
What is the silver melt value of an 1843 dime?
The 1843 Seated Liberty Dime contains 0.0773 troy ounces of silver. At a spot price of $48.00 per troy ounce, the melt value is approximately $3.71. However, this is purely academic—even the most heavily worn 1843 dimes are worth several times their melt value due to numismatic demand. For the 1843-O key date and proof specimens, the numismatic value is hundreds or thousands of times the melt value. Never sell an 1843 dime for melt value.
How do I distinguish strike weakness from wear?
Strike weakness appears as flat or mushy details that lack definition, but the coin retains its original luster and shows no friction on the high points. Circulation wear shows as friction, loss of luster, and smoothing of the highest points of the design. Seated Liberty Dimes, especially from New Orleans, frequently exhibit weak strikes on Liberty's head, stars, or shield. A professional grader assesses luster and friction patterns to determine whether flatness is from striking or circulation. Learning this distinction is critical for accurate grading.
Are there any significant errors known for 1843 dimes?
No major, widely publicized mint errors are documented for the 1843 dime, but several error types are plausible: off-center strikes, die cracks, die clashes, and lamination errors. Values depend on the type and severity of the error. Minor die cracks and die clashes are relatively common and add minimal value ($20-$50). Dramatic off-center strikes with the date visible could be worth several hundred dollars. Any significant error should be authenticated by a reputable certification service before purchase or sale.
What is the difference between a business strike and a proof?
Business strikes were produced for general circulation using standard dies and planchets. Proof coins were struck using specially prepared, polished dies and polished planchets, resulting in mirrored fields and frosted design elements. Proofs were made in tiny quantities for presentation purposes and collectors. For 1843, only 8-10 proof dimes were struck compared to over 1.5 million business strikes. Proofs exhibit razor-sharp details and reflective surfaces that are immediately distinguishable from business strikes under proper lighting.
Methodology and Data Sources
The valuations and information presented in this guide are compiled from authoritative numismatic sources, including PCGS CoinFacts, NGC Coin Explorer, major auction records, and specialized references such as Gerry Fortin's Comprehensive Guide to Liberty Seated Dimes and the Fivaz-Stanton Cherrypickers' Guide. Price data reflects historical market information from dated price guides and recent auction results, providing a comprehensive view of market trends. Auction records cited include sale dates and grading service designations for transparency.
The coin market is dynamic, and values fluctuate based on precious metal prices, collector demand, and the availability of high-grade specimens. The prices in this guide represent historical data and general market ranges. For current values, consult recent auction results, dealer listings, and updated price guides. Professional authentication and grading by PCGS or NGC is strongly recommended for valuable specimens, particularly the 1843-O key date and proof issues. When considering a purchase or sale, seek guidance from experienced numismatic professionals who can assess the specific coin's characteristics, market conditions, and current demand.
