1940 Nickel Value: Worth $0.10 to $21,738 | Complete Guide
1940 Jefferson Nickel values: circulated $0.10-$2, uncirculated $2-$558, Full Steps $10-$21,738, Proofs $50-$18,400. Mintage, grades, varieties & errors explained.
The 1940 Jefferson Nickel is worth $0.10 to $21,738 depending on mint mark, condition, and strike quality.
- Circulated (G-4 to AU-50): $0.10 – $2.00
- Uncirculated (MS-60 to MS-68): $2.00 – $558
- Full Steps designation: $10 – $21,738 (MS-63FS to MS-68FS)
- Proof strikes: $50 – $18,400 (standard to Cameo)
- Top specimens: $21,738 for 1940-D MS-68FS (auction record, May 2018)
Value is driven almost entirely by strike quality (Full Steps) and preservation—the Full Steps designation can increase value tenfold or more.
What's Your 1940 Nickel Worth?
Select your coin's mint mark and condition to get a value estimate.
Focus on choosing the right sales channel to maximize your return.
Expected: ()
1940 Jefferson Nickel: From Pocket Change to Trophy Coin
The 1940 Jefferson Nickel features Felix Schlag's iconic design of Thomas Jefferson and his Virginia home, Monticello.
The 1940 Jefferson Nickel represents a cornerstone year of the Jefferson Nickel series (1938-Date), designed by Felix Schlag. Struck in a 75% Copper, 25% Nickel composition, these coins have a combined business strike mintage exceeding 260 million across three mints—Philadelphia (176,485,000), Denver (43,540,000), and San Francisco (39,690,000)—plus a small collector mintage of just 14,158 Proof specimens.
The 1940 nickel market presents an extreme dichotomy rarely seen in numismatics. A typical circulated example trades for as little as ten cents, yet a 1940-D graded MS-68 with the Full Steps designation commanded $21,738 at auction in May 2018. This 200,000-fold value difference illustrates a fundamental truth: for common-date Jefferson Nickels, value derives exclusively from condition and strike quality, not scarcity.
This comprehensive guide covers identification, market values across all grades and mint marks, die varieties including the prominent 1940-S/S repunched mint mark, mint errors, authentication, and preservation techniques for this classic American coin.
Identifying Your 1940 Nickel: Design Features and Mint Marks
Mint mark location on 1940 nickels: to the right of Monticello building on the reverse.
The 1940 Jefferson Nickel features Felix Schlag's winning design from the 1938 design competition. The obverse displays a left-facing portrait of Thomas Jefferson, the third U.S. President. The motto "IN GOD WE TRUST" appears on the left side of the portrait, while "LIBERTY * 1940" curves along the right edge. Jefferson's distinctive profile shows significant detail in his hair, with individual strands visible on well-struck specimens.
The reverse depicts Monticello, Jefferson's architectural masterpiece and Virginia home. Above the building appears the motto "E PLURIBUS UNUM." Below Monticello, centered, is the inscription "MONTICELLO," with "FIVE CENTS" directly below that, and "UNITED STATES OF AMERICA" at the bottom rim. The building's portico features six columns and a distinctive set of steps leading to the entrance—these steps are critical for grading and value determination.
Mint Mark Location and Identification
For all 1940-dated Jefferson Nickels, the mint mark appears on the reverse, to the right of the Monticello building, positioned between the building's edge and the coin's rim. The three possible designations are:
- No Mint Mark: Indicates the coin was struck at the Philadelphia Mint (176,485,000 mintage)
- "D" Mint Mark: Denver Mint (43,540,000 mintage)
- "S" Mint Mark: San Francisco Mint (39,690,000 mintage)
Note that while the 1940-S had the lowest business strike mintage, this does not make it the most valuable issue—strike quality trumps mintage for this date.
The Reverse of 1940 vs. Reverse of 1938
In 1939, the U.S. Mint introduced a modified reverse die known as the "Reverse of 1940," featuring sharpened details particularly on Monticello's steps. All 1940-dated business strikes use this improved reverse design. However, a rare variety exists: a small number of 1940 Proof coins were struck using leftover "Reverse of 1938" dies, identifiable by their softer details and weak, wavy step definition. This variety is highly sought after by specialists.
Business Strike vs. Proof Distinction
Standard circulation strikes (business strikes) have a satiny, frosty luster and were struck once under normal pressure. Proof coins, struck specifically for collectors, were produced using specially prepared planchets and dies, struck multiple times under high pressure to create deep mirror-like fields. The 1940 Proof mintage of 14,158 makes these coins considerably scarcer than business strikes, though value ultimately depends on preservation and contrast quality (Cameo designation).
1940 Nickel Values: Complete Price Guide by Mint and Grade
The market for 1940 Jefferson Nickels is segmented by mint mark, grade, and most critically, strike quality. This section provides retail value estimates for all major categories based on November 2025 pricing data from PCGS, NGC, and recent auction results. All values represent coins certified by major grading services (PCGS, NGC, ANACS) unless otherwise noted.
1940 (P) Philadelphia – No Mint Mark
The Philadelphia issue represents the highest mintage of the year at 176,485,000 pieces, making it extremely common in all grades. Circulated examples have minimal value above face value. However, at the uppermost end of the preservation spectrum, significant premiums emerge. A PCGS MS-68 (non-Full Steps) specimen realized $558 at Heritage Auctions in April 2021.
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $0.10 |
| VF-20 | $0.30 |
| EF-40 | $0.50 |
| AU-50 | $0.90 |
| MS-60 | $2.00 |
| MS-63 | $4.00 |
| MS-65 | $20.00 |
| MS-67 | $100.00 |
| MS-68 | $558 |
1940 (P) Philadelphia – Full Steps
The Full Steps (FS) designation transforms the value proposition. This certification indicates at least five complete, uninterrupted steps on Monticello are visible—a sign of exceptional strike quality. NGC differentiates between 5FS (five complete steps) and 6FS (six complete steps), while PCGS uses a single FS designation. The auction record for a 1940 (P) Full Steps is $6,463 for a PCGS MS-68FS, sold by Heritage Auctions in March 2016. (PCGS CoinFacts)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| MS-63 FS | $20 |
| MS-64 FS | $30 – $70 |
| MS-65 FS | $40 – $50 |
| MS-66 FS | $75 – $100 |
| MS-67 FS | $270 |
| MS-67+ FS | $500+ |
| MS-68 FS | $6,463 |
1940-D Denver Mint
The Denver issue has a mintage of 43,540,000, making it scarcer than Philadelphia but still quite common. NGC notes that most 1940-D nickels were "quite well made, with most having good strikes and very pleasing luster," which makes Gem (MS-65+) examples relatively available. (NGC Coin Explorer)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $0.10 |
| VF-20 | $0.30 |
| EF-40 | $0.50 |
| AU-50 | $1.25 |
| MS-60 | $2.50 |
| MS-63 | $5.25 |
| MS-65 | $25.00 |
| MS-67 | $125.00 |
1940-D Denver Mint – Full Steps
The 1940-D Full Steps represents the crown jewel of the entire 1940 series. Despite having a higher mintage than the San Francisco issue, the 1940-D FS commands dramatically higher prices due to extreme strike rarity. This counterintuitive reality teaches a crucial lesson: mintage figures do not determine rarity for condition rarities. The auction record of $21,738 for a PCGS MS-68FS, sold at Legend Rare Coin Auctions in May 2018, stands as the highest price realized for any 1940 nickel. (PCGS CoinFacts)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| MS-63 FS | $10 |
| MS-64 FS | $15 |
| MS-65 FS | $26 |
| MS-66 FS | $60 |
| MS-67 FS | $225 |
| MS-67+ FS | $950 |
| MS-68 FS | $21,738 |
1940-S San Francisco Mint
With a mintage of 39,690,000, the 1940-S has the lowest production of the three business strikes. However, NGC notes that most 1940-S nickels were "poorly made from tired dies having obvious signs of heavy erosion" with "sub-par luster," which affects the availability of high-grade examples. (NGC Coin Explorer)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| G-4 | $1.00 |
| VF-20 | $2.00 |
| EF-40 | $3.00 |
| AU-50 | $2.00 |
| MS-60 | $4.00 |
| MS-63 | $8.00 |
| MS-65 | $25.00 |
| MS-67 | $250.00 |
1940-S San Francisco Mint – Full Steps
PCGS analysis indicates the 1940-S had "good striking characteristics," with a "high percentage" of Mint State survivors exhibiting Full Steps. This relative availability causes the 1940-S FS to be more accessible than its Denver counterpart, though still scarce in top grades. The auction record is $5,170 for a PCGS MS-67+FS, sold in June 2015. (PCGS Auction Prices)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| MS-63 FS | $16 |
| MS-64 FS | $25 |
| MS-65 FS | $65 |
| MS-66 FS | $110 |
| MS-67 FS | $775 |
| MS-67+ FS | $5,170 |
1940 Proof – Standard Brilliant Finish
In 1940, the Philadelphia Mint produced 14,158 Proof coins for collectors using specially prepared dies and planchets struck multiple times under high pressure. These coins feature deep mirror-like fields and sharp devices. The standard "brilliant" Proof finish lacks the frosted-device contrast of Cameo specimens but still represents a significant key issue due to the low mintage. A PF-68 specimen (non-Cameo) sold for $18,400 at auction in 2005, while another high-grade Proof with "beautiful rainbow patina" realized $15,275 in 2017. (BOLD Precious Metals)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| PR-63 | $50 – $75 |
| PR-65 | $90 – $115 |
| PR-66 | $130 – $150 |
| PR-67 | $275 – $290 |
| PR-68 | $18,400 |
1940 Proof – Cameo (CAM)
The Cameo designation certifies noticeable contrast between mirrored fields and frosted devices (Jefferson's portrait and Monticello). This finish was not an intentional mint goal in 1940 and only appeared on coins struck from freshly prepared dies, making Cameo examples scarce. NGC confirms these are "scarce" compared to standard Proofs. A PR-65 Cameo is valued at over ten times its non-Cameo counterpart, demonstrating the significant premium for this contrast quality. (PCGS CoinFacts)
| Grade | Value |
|---|---|
| PR-63 CAM | $135 |
| PR-64 CAM | $300 |
| PR-65 CAM | $1,150 |
| PR-66 CAM | ~$1,400 |
Note: Deep Cameo (DCAM) examples of 1940 Proofs are exceptionally rare for this era and trade infrequently. No reliable public pricing is available, though dealer asking prices as high as $34,000 have been noted for top-population specimens.
Grading 1940 Nickels: Understanding Wear, Strike, and Condition
Grade comparison: G-4 shows heavy wear, VF-20 moderate wear with visible details, MS-65 original mint luster.
Grading Jefferson Nickels requires understanding both wear (the amount of metal lost through circulation) and strike quality (how sharply the design was impressed during minting). Unlike silver coins where luster and toning play major roles, nickel grading focuses heavily on surface preservation and strike completeness. For 1940 nickels specifically, the distinction between a common coin and a valuable specimen often comes down to the sharpness of Monticello's steps.
Circulated Grades (G-4 through AU-58)
Good-4 (G-4): Heavy wear across all design elements. Jefferson's portrait shows only major features with hair detail completely merged. On the reverse, Monticello's columns blend together and steps are indistinguishable. Rim may be worn into design elements. Date and mint mark must be readable, though may be weak.
Very Fine-20 (VF-20): Moderate wear evident but all major design elements remain clear. Jefferson's hair shows distinct separation with some individual strands visible on the higher points. Cheekbone detail remains. On Monticello, columns are clearly separated and step definition begins to emerge, though steps show significant flatness. This grade represents the transitional point where numismatic interest begins.
Extremely Fine-40 (EF-40): Light wear confined to the highest design points. Jefferson's hair retains considerable detail with most major strands visible. On Monticello, architectural details are sharp with moderate step definition visible. Wear is primarily seen on the building's high points and column tops. Original mint luster may be visible in protected areas.
About Uncirculated-50/58 (AU-50/58): Minimal wear visible only on the highest design points. Jefferson's hair shows nearly complete detail, with slight flattening only on the uppermost strands above the ear. Monticello steps show good definition but may lack complete separation. Significant original luster remains (50% or more), giving the coin a "slider" appearance—nearly mint state but with detectable wear under magnification.
Strike quality dramatically affects value: strong strikes show full hair details and complete step separation.
Uncirculated Grades (MS-60 through MS-70)
MS-60 to MS-62: No wear, but numerous contact marks and surface imperfections limit eye appeal. Luster may be impaired or "broken" by heavy bag marks. For 1940 nickels, these grades represent coins that survived without circulation damage but suffered handling during production, storage, or counting.
MS-63 to MS-64: Moderate to limited contact marks with good overall eye appeal. Original mint luster is strong but may show minor impairments. Strike quality becomes increasingly important at these grades. A weakly struck MS-64 may have indistinct Monticello steps despite having no wear, while a sharply struck MS-64 shows good step separation but falls short of Full Steps criteria due to minor incompleteness.
MS-65 to MS-66 (Gem): Few contact marks, none in focal areas like Jefferson's cheek or Monticello's central portico. Strong, unbroken mint luster with excellent eye appeal. Strike quality variations become dramatic value factors. A common MS-65 1940-D may be worth $25, while an MS-65FS can command $26 or more—though the real premiums appear at MS-67 and above.
Full Steps (FS) designation requires at least five complete, uninterrupted steps visible on Monticello.
The Full Steps Designation: Critical Value Driver
The Full Steps (FS) designation is applied only to Mint State coins (MS-60 or higher) that exhibit complete, uninterrupted horizontal lines representing Monticello's steps. This designation recognizes exceptional strike quality—a coin that escaped the weak strikes common to the series. The two major grading services differ slightly:
- PCGS (FS): Requires at least five full, separate steps. Allows for very slight weakness or interruption on a single step as long as five steps remain clearly defined.
- NGC (5FS and 6FS): Uses two distinct designations. "5FS" certifies five complete, uninterrupted steps. "6FS" certifies all six steps are complete and uninterrupted, representing absolute striking perfection.
For 1940 nickels, the Full Steps designation can increase value tenfold or more. A 1940-D MS-67 without Full Steps is worth approximately $125, while an MS-67FS commands $225 or more. At MS-68, the difference becomes extreme: non-FS examples are rare but FS examples set auction records in the five-figure range.
Key Diagnostic Areas for 1940 Nickels
Obverse: Examine Jefferson's hair detail, particularly above the ear and at the back of the head. Look for the fine horizontal strands. Check the cheekbone for smoothness—wear or striking weakness here affects grade. Inspect the field areas (open spaces) for contact marks, as these reduce grade regardless of design sharpness.
Reverse: Focus on Monticello's steps first—this is the single most important diagnostic area. Count the visible horizontal step lines. Then examine the six columns—they should be distinct with visible separation. Check the triangular pediment (the architectural feature above the columns) for sharp detail. Finally, assess the overall field quality for marks or disturbances.
Luster Quality: Original "cartwheel" luster—the rotating band of light visible when the coin is tilted under a lamp—is crucial. This luster should be unbroken, flowing smoothly across the surface. Impaired or "matte" luster indicates possible cleaning or environmental damage, which severely limits grade and value.
Strike vs. Wear: A Common Confusion
Beginning collectors often confuse weak strike with wear. A weakly struck coin may show soft, indistinct details on high-relief areas (like Monticello's steps) but will have complete, unbroken luster and no metal displacement. Wear creates a different texture—polished-looking flat spots with disturbed luster and metal flow. Weak strike is a mint-made characteristic; wear is post-mint damage from handling or circulation.
1940 Nickel Die Varieties: RPMs and Reverse Types
Major variety: 1940-S/S RPM (FS-501) shows clear secondary S mint mark below primary S.
Die varieties are variations in a coin's design caused by abnormalities in the die itself, not from striking errors. For the 1940 Jefferson Nickel, several die varieties have been documented, ranging from minor curiosities to significant numismatic rarities. Repunched Mint Marks (RPMs) dominate the variety landscape for this year.
1940-S/S Repunched Mint Mark (FS-501)
This is the most prominent and sought-after variety for the entire 1940 series. Cataloged as FS-501 in Fivaz-Stanton references and RPM-001 by Variety Vista, this variety shows a clear secondary "S" mint mark punched below (South of) the primary "S." The repunching is easily visible with 5x to 10x magnification and shows as a distinct doubled outline of the entire letter.
Identification: Examine the S mint mark on the reverse to the right of Monticello. Look for a secondary S impression extending downward from the base of the primary S. The secondary impression is particularly visible on the lower curve of the letter. This is not a subtle variety—once you know what to look for, the doubling is unmistakable.
Value Premium: The 1940-S/S RPM commands a strong premium across all grades:
- Circulated: $4.00 – $10.00
- AU/Uncertified Uncirculated: $85.00
- MS-65 (non-FS): $225 – $230
- MS-65 FS: ~$119
- MS-66 FS: $609.99 (auction record)
This variety represents one of the best opportunities for variety collectors in the Jefferson Nickel series, as it combines visibility, scarcity, and reasonable affordability in mid-grades.
1940-D Repunched Mint Marks (Minor Varieties)
The Denver Mint produced several minor RPM varieties in 1940, though none approach the prominence of the 1940-S/S. Two cataloged examples include:
FS-501 (RPM-002): D/D West – Shows minor doubling of the D mint mark with the secondary impression visible to the west (left) of the primary D. The doubling is subtle and requires magnification to detect.
FS-502 (RPM-001): D/D South or Rotated Clockwise – Shows very minor doubling or slight rotation of the D mint mark. The secondary impression extends slightly downward from the primary D.
These varieties have "not developed much of a following" among mainstream collectors according to NGC commentary. They carry minimal premiums, typically $15-$20 over common date values in uncirculated grades. For completists and variety specialists only.
1940 (P) Doubled Die Obverse Varieties
At least two different Doubled Die Obverse (DDO) varieties are documented for the Philadelphia issue. These show minor doubling on Jefferson's portrait elements or the date digits. Unlike the dramatic 1939 "Doubled Monticello" variety, the 1940 DDOs are not visually striking and have "attracted little interest" from collectors. No reliable public pricing exists for these varieties—they are primarily of interest to error and variety specialists who pursue comprehensive collections of the series.
Major Proof Variety: 1940 Reverse of 1938
This represents the most significant variety in the 1940 series from a numismatic standpoint. In 1939, the U.S. Mint introduced a new reverse die known as the "Reverse of 1940," which featured sharpened design details, particularly on Monticello's steps. This improved design was used for all 1940 business strikes and nearly all 1940 Proofs.
However, a very small number of 1940 Proof coins were struck using leftover "Reverse of 1938" dies. These can be identified by examining the steps of Monticello, which show the softer, less-defined, wavy appearance characteristic of the earlier design. The contrast is particularly dramatic on Proof coins, where the strike is expected to be sharp—the weak, ill-defined steps immediately signal the use of the older reverse die.
Value: In top grades, the 1940 Proof Reverse of 1938 variety is valued at up to $25,000. PCGS formally recognizes this variety with its own designation: "1940 Reverse of 1938 PR." This is a major specialty item for advanced Jefferson Nickel collectors and proof specialists.
1940 Nickel Mint Errors: Types and Market Values
Mint errors occur during the production process due to mechanical malfunctions, die failures, or planchet defects. Unlike die varieties, which are reproduced across multiple coins, errors are typically unique to individual pieces. The 1940 Jefferson Nickel exhibits the full range of error types common to the series, though values vary dramatically based on error type, severity, and visual appeal.
Off-Center Strikes
This error occurs when the coin blank (planchet) is not properly seated in the coining press, causing the dies to strike partially off the planchet. The result is a coin showing the design struck off-center with a portion of blank planchet visible as a crescent or arc. Off-center strikes are among the most visually dramatic and collectible mint errors.
Identification: Look for the design elements pushed to one side of the coin with blank planchet visible on the opposite edge. The key diagnostic is the missing design—you can clearly see where the die did not strike the metal.
Value Factors: Two elements determine value: the percentage the design is off-center and whether the date and mint mark remain visible. An off-center strike that obscures the date or mint mark is generally less valuable because authentication becomes difficult.
- 10% – 20% Off-Center (AU/MS, date visible): $50 – $100
- 50% Off-Center (date visible): $150 or more
- Off-center with damaged details or "Details" grade: Minimal value—the error premium is negated by the damage grade
A 1940-S nickel struck approximately 20% off-center but graded "AU50 Details, Scratched" by ANACS demonstrates how condition issues can eliminate the error premium—the scratch damage overrides the collectibility of the off-center strike.
Lamination Errors
Lamination errors are particularly common for the 75% Copper, 25% Nickel alloy used in Jefferson Nickels. These errors occur when an impurity or flaw in the metal blank causes a thin layer of metal to peel, flake, or separate from the coin's surface, either before or after the strike. The result ranges from small surface flakes to large areas of missing metal.
Identification: Look for areas where the surface metal has lifted, peeled away, or separated in thin layers. Laminations can appear as bubbles, flakes, or missing patches of metal. They differ from damage in that the edges are typically smooth and show the layered structure of the metal alloy.
Value Determination: Lamination error values depend entirely on size, location, and visual impact. A small flake on the edge may add $5 to a coin's value, while a dramatic peel covering major design elements may command $20 or more in uncirculated condition.
- Minor Flake (Circulated): $5.00
- Major Peel (Uncirculated): $12.50 – $20.00
Note that unrealistic dealer asking prices (sometimes as high as $289) may be encountered online but do not reflect actual market value. The error coin market values dramatic, aesthetically appealing errors; small laminations are common and relatively inexpensive.
Die Cracks and Cuds
Die cracks occur when the die used to strike coins develops a crack from metal fatigue. When the die strikes a planchet, metal flows into the crack, creating a raised, jagged line on the finished coin. If a piece of the die breaks away completely, the result is a "retained cud"—a blank, raised area on the coin where design elements are missing.
Identification: Die cracks appear as raised lines, often irregular or jagged, running across the coin's surface. They may connect design elements or extend from the rim into the field. Cuds appear as raised, blank areas (often at the rim) where part of the die has broken away.
Value: Die cracks are extremely common on 1940 nickels and add little to no value ($0-$1) unless they are exceptionally dramatic. Large retained cuds affecting major design elements can command modest premiums, but most die cracks are considered minor production anomalies rather than collectible errors.
Die Clashes
A die clash occurs when the obverse and reverse dies strike each other without a planchet between them. This causes a partial impression of the reverse design to be transferred onto the obverse die (and vice versa). When these clashed dies are subsequently used to strike coins, faint "ghosted" images of the opposite side's design appear on the finished coins.
Identification: Look for faint outlines or shadowy impressions of the reverse design appearing on the obverse fields, or vice versa. On 1940 nickels, you might see faint traces of Monticello's columns on the obverse field areas, or traces of Jefferson's portrait on the reverse.
Value: Like die cracks, die clashes are common and add little value unless very strong and visually dramatic. Most clash marks visible on 1940 nickels are subtle and carry premiums of $0-$1. Only exceptionally strong clashes with clear, visible design transfer command modest collector interest.
Authentication: Detecting Counterfeits and Altered Coins
Cleaned coins show hairline scratches, unnatural shine, and impaired original luster—dramatically reducing value.
The 1940 Jefferson Nickel, being a common date with high surviving populations, is not a frequent target of sophisticated counterfeiting operations. However, collectors and researchers must be aware of several authentication pitfalls, particularly regarding the Henning counterfeit issue and altered mint marks. More importantly, understanding how to identify cleaned or damaged "problem coins" is critical, as these conditions destroy numismatic value far more frequently than counterfeits.
The Henning Counterfeit Clarification: Researchers may encounter information about the "Henning Nickel"—a famous series of counterfeit Jefferson Nickels produced by Francis LeRoy Henning in the 1950s. These counterfeits are identifiable by specific diagnostics including a looped "R" in PLURIBUS and a heavier weight (approximately 5.4 grams versus the standard 5.0 grams). However, it is critical to note that 1940 is NOT a known date for the Henning counterfeit. Henning's documented counterfeit dates are 1939, 1944, 1946, 1947, and 1953, with the 1944 being most famous because it lacks the large "P" mint mark that all genuine 1944 war nickels possess. Any "Henning-like" characteristics observed on a 1940 nickel are simple die flaws or damage, not evidence of a valuable counterfeit.
Altered Mint Marks: While uncommon for this date given the modest value differences, a researcher might encounter a 1940 (P) nickel where a "D" or "S" mint mark has been added to deceive collectors. These alterations are usually crude and detectable under magnification by examining several factors: the mint mark may appear unnaturally raised or incused compared to genuine strikes, a seam or edge may be visible around the mark indicating it was punched or soldered on, the metal luster around the mint mark may differ from the surrounding surface, or the mint mark's position may be slightly off from the correct location. When in doubt, comparison with certified examples is recommended.
Detecting Cleaned Coins: The greatest authentication threat—and the most common problem affecting 1940 nickel values—is improper cleaning. A cleaned or damaged coin receives a "Details" grade from professional grading services (e.g., "MS Details - Cleaned") and is worth only a fraction of its problem-free counterpart. Key warning signs include fine, parallel scratches or "hairlines" across the coin's surface, especially in open field areas, indicating abrasive cleaning with cloths, brushes, or jewelry cleaners. An unnaturally brilliant, "burnished," or waxy shine suggests polishing or "whizzing," a process that removes original mint luster to create a fake high-gloss surface. A dull, lifeless appearance with uniform, unnatural coloring indicates chemical cleaning or "dipping," which removes the original "cartwheel" luster—the rotating band of light visible when tilting the coin under a lamp. Chemical residue may be visible in crevices around letters and design elements.
The fundamental rule is that original mint luster has a specific quality that cannot be replicated once destroyed. Cleaned coins lack the flowing, unbroken luster of untouched pieces and show surface disturbances under proper lighting. When purchasing significant 1940 nickels, especially Full Steps examples or Proofs, certification by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS provides authentication of both genuineness and problem-free status.
Preservation and Storage: Protecting Your 1940 Nickels
The cardinal rule of numismatics applies with particular force to nickel coinage: DO NOT CLEAN YOUR COINS. Any attempt to "improve" a coin's appearance through scrubbing, polishing, or chemical treatments will permanently damage the surface and destroy numismatic value. Even a common 1940 nickel worth a few dollars in original condition becomes essentially worthless when cleaned, while a cleaned Full Steps specimen loses hundreds or thousands of dollars in value.
Proper preservation begins with the understanding that a coin's surface is its most critical feature. The original mint luster—the result of metal flow during the striking process—cannot be restored once disturbed. Environmental exposure, handling oils, and atmospheric contaminants naturally affect coins over time, but proper storage dramatically slows degradation.
Storage Recommendations: Store 1940 nickels in inert, stable holders made from materials that will not react with the copper-nickel alloy. Mylar 2x2 flips (the cardboard holders with clear plastic windows) using inert plastics are suitable for most purposes. Avoid soft PVC (polyvinyl chloride) flips, which degrade over time and release acidic compounds that cause green spots and surface damage. For valuable specimens—particularly Full Steps examples, Proofs, or rare varieties—consider professional encapsulation by PCGS or NGC, which provides both authentication and archival-quality protection.
Store coins in a stable environment with moderate temperature and humidity. Extreme fluctuations in temperature can cause condensation, which accelerates toning and potential corrosion. Avoid storage in damp basements or hot attics. A climate-controlled interior space is ideal. Keep coins away from sulfur-containing materials (rubber bands, certain papers, wool) which can accelerate toning on copper-nickel coins.
Handling Guidelines: Handle coins by their edges only, never touching the obverse or reverse surfaces. Skin oils contain acids and salts that will leave permanent fingerprints. If you must examine a coin outside its holder, hold it over a soft surface and use clean cotton gloves if handling repeatedly. Never use your fingers to rub or "test" a coin's luster—this creates permanent marks.
For 1940 nickels with original cartwheel luster, preservation of that surface quality is paramount. Even minor surface disturbances reduce grade and value. The difference between MS-66 and MS-67 can be a single additional contact mark, representing a value difference of hundreds of dollars for Full Steps coins. Proper storage and handling practices maintain the investment value you've acquired.
Frequently Asked Questions About 1940 Nickels
How much is my 1940 nickel worth?
A typical circulated 1940 nickel is worth between $0.10 and $2.00 depending on condition and mint mark. Uncirculated examples range from $2 to over $500 depending on grade and strike quality. The critical value factors are: (1) mint mark (P, D, or S), (2) condition/grade, and (3) whether the coin has the Full Steps (FS) designation. A common 1940-D in circulated condition is worth around $0.30, while a 1940-D MS-68 with Full Steps holds an auction record of $21,738. Proof coins with the low mintage of 14,158 range from $50 in PR-63 to $18,400 in PR-68, with Cameo examples commanding significant premiums.
How do I identify the mint mark on a 1940 nickel?
The mint mark on 1940 Jefferson Nickels appears on the reverse (back) of the coin, to the right of the Monticello building. Look between the building's edge and the coin's rim. You will see either no mint mark (indicating Philadelphia), a "D" (Denver), or an "S" (San Francisco). The mint mark is typically small, requiring good lighting or magnification to see clearly, especially if the coin is worn. If no mint mark is visible, the coin was struck at the Philadelphia Mint, which produced 176,485,000 pieces—the highest mintage of the year.
What is the Full Steps (FS) designation and why does it matter?
The Full Steps designation is a special certification applied only to Mint State 1940 nickels that exhibit at least five complete, uninterrupted horizontal step lines on the Monticello building's portico. Because Monticello's steps are a high point of the design, they were often struck weakly during production, with details blending together or incomplete. Coins with Full Steps demonstrate exceptional strike quality—they escaped the weak strikes common to the series. PCGS uses a single "FS" designation, while NGC differentiates between "5FS" (five complete steps) and "6FS" (six complete steps). This designation can increase a coin's value tenfold or more, particularly in high grades. The 1940-D in MS-68FS holds the record at $21,738, while a non-FS MS-67 might be worth only $125.
Should I get my 1940 nickel professionally graded?
Professional grading is cost-effective only for coins likely to grade MS-65 or higher, or for specimens with the Full Steps designation, rare varieties (like the 1940-S/S RPM), or Proof coins. Grading fees typically range from $20 to $50+ per coin depending on service level, so the coin must have sufficient value to justify the expense. For common circulated 1940 nickels worth $0.10 to $5, grading is not economically justified. However, if you have an uncirculated specimen with sharp Monticello steps, no visible contact marks, and strong luster, professional authentication and grading by PCGS or NGC can add significant value and marketability. The FS designation alone can transform a $20 coin into a $200+ coin.
What is the 1940-S/S repunched mint mark variety?
The 1940-S/S RPM (cataloged as FS-501) is the most prominent die variety for 1940 nickels. This variety shows a clear secondary "S" mint mark punched below (South of) the primary "S" on the reverse. The repunching occurred when the mint worker initially placed the mint mark punch in an incorrect position, then corrected it by punching again in the proper location. The secondary impression remains visible as a distinct outline extending downward from the base of the primary S. This variety is easily detected with 5x to 10x magnification and commands strong premiums: $4-$10 in circulated grades, $85 uncertified uncirculated, $225-$230 in MS-65, and up to $610 for MS-66 FS examples. It represents one of the best opportunities in Jefferson Nickel variety collecting.
Are 1940 nickels made of silver?
No. The 1940 Jefferson Nickel is composed of 75% Copper and 25% Nickel, with no silver content. The "wartime" silver nickels (35% silver composition) were produced only from mid-1942 through 1945 and are easily distinguished by a large mint mark above Monticello on the reverse. All 1940-dated nickels use the standard copper-nickel composition. The melt value of a 1940 nickel is approximately $0.06 based on current base metal prices, which is negligible compared to even the lowest numismatic values. The coin's value comes from its collectibility and condition, not its metal content.
How can I tell if my 1940 nickel has been cleaned?
Cleaned coins show several telltale signs: fine parallel scratches or "hairlines" across the surface (especially in field areas), an unnaturally bright or waxy shine indicating polishing, a dull or lifeless appearance with impaired luster from chemical treatments, or an unnatural uniform coloring. The key diagnostic is the original "cartwheel" luster—when you tilt an uncleaned coin under a light source, you should see a rotating band of light flow smoothly across the surface. Cleaned coins lack this characteristic luster pattern. Chemical residue may be visible in crevices around letters and design elements. Cleaning permanently damages a coin and causes it to receive a "Details" grade (e.g., "MS Details - Cleaned") from grading services, reducing value to a fraction of a problem-free coin's worth. The cardinal rule: never clean coins under any circumstances.
What is the rarest 1940 nickel?
From a pure mintage standpoint, the 1940 Proof is the rarest with only 14,158 struck. However, "rarity" in numismatics often means "condition rarity"—scarcity in specific high grades. The rarest 1940 nickel in practical terms is the 1940-D in MS-68 with Full Steps, which has the highest auction record at $21,738. Despite having a higher mintage than the 1940-S (43.5 million vs. 39.7 million), the 1940-D is dramatically rarer with Full Steps due to poor striking quality at the Denver Mint that year. Among Proofs, the 1940 Reverse of 1938 variety is the rarest, valued up to $25,000 in top grades. Deep Cameo (DCAM) Proofs are also exceptionally rare for this era, though they trade so infrequently that establishing market values is difficult.
Can I spend a 1940 nickel as regular currency?
Yes, 1940 nickels remain legal tender with a face value of five cents and can technically be spent. However, even the most worn 1940 nickel has a numismatic value of at least $0.10 to $0.30, which exceeds face value. More importantly, any uncirculated specimen, Full Steps example, or proof coin has substantial collector value ranging from dollars to thousands of dollars. Spending such a coin would result in immediate loss of its numismatic premium. Before spending any 1940 nickel, check its condition and mint mark—you may have a coin worth considerably more than five cents.
Where can I sell my 1940 nickel?
For common circulated 1940 nickels worth under $5, your options include local coin shops (expect wholesale pricing, typically 50-70% of retail), online marketplaces like eBay (requires photography, listing effort, and fees), or keeping the coin as it has modest value. For higher-grade examples, Full Steps specimens, or rare varieties worth $50+, consider specialized dealers who focus on Jefferson Nickels, consignment through reputable auction houses (Heritage Auctions, GreatCollections, Stack's Bowers), or selling to active collectors through coin forums and clubs. For specimens worth $500+, professional auction is typically the best route to achieve full market value, as the auction format exposes the coin to the broadest pool of serious collectors. Always get multiple offers and verify buyer reputations before selling significant coins.
Methodology and Sources
This comprehensive value guide for 1940 Jefferson Nickels is based on analysis of multiple authoritative numismatic sources as of November 2025. Primary pricing data derives from PCGS CoinFacts and NGC Coin Explorer price guides, which reflect current retail market values. Auction records cited throughout are documented transactions from Heritage Auctions, Legend Rare Coin Auctions, and GreatCollections, with dates and prices as stated.
Technical specifications (composition, weight, diameter) and mintage figures are verified through PCGS CoinFacts, Jefferson Nickel.org, and U.S. Mint historical records. Die variety information is sourced from Variety Vista and Fivaz-Stanton catalogs. Melt value calculations use commodity pricing from Trading Economics and Kitco as of November 2025.
It is important to note that numismatic markets fluctuate based on collector demand, economic conditions, and the availability of high-grade examples. Values presented represent retail estimates for certified coins in problem-free condition. Actual selling prices may vary based on market timing, coin eye appeal, and buyer-seller negotiations. Auction records cited represent the highest prices realized for specific coins and may not reflect typical market values for the grade. Collectors should obtain multiple price points and consider professional appraisal for significant purchases or sales.
