The values provided are estimates based on the PCGS Price Guide and vary depending on the condition of the coins. For a detailed breakdown of values by grade or to view auction data for a specific coin, please click on the [coin name] in the table chart, which serves as a direct hyperlink to more information.
| Abbreviation | Grade | Description |
|---|---|---|
| PO | Poor | Coin is heavily worn, with details and inscriptions barely visible. |
| FR | Fair | Coin is very worn, but some details remain visible. |
| AG | About Good | Coin shows heavy wear, but major design elements are clear. |
| G | Good | Moderate to heavy even wear, but most major details are visible. |
| VG | Very Good | Minor wear on high points, design and lettering are clear. |
| F | Fine | Light to moderate even wear, with all details visible. |
| VF | Very Fine | Light even wear, with most fine details still sharp. |
| XF | Extremely Fine | Minimal wear on high points, with all details sharp and mint luster may be present. |
| AU | About Uncirculated | Slight wear on high points, with most or all mint luster intact. |
| MS | Uncirculated/Mint State | No wear, as minted with full original luster (graded from MS-60 to MS-70 based on imperfections). |
To simplify the table column names, we will use abbreviations.
| Coin Name | PO, FR And AG | G And VG | F And VF | XF | AU | MS | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1857 Penny Flying Eagle (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $5,000.00~$85,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Small Letters (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $4,350.00~$60,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Large Letters (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $4,500.00~$45,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle (Regular Strike) | $6,000.00 | $7,000.00~$9,500.00 | $11,250.00~$12,850.00 | $13,500.00~$14,150.00 | $14,250.00~$17,650.00 | $18,000.00~$225,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny Flying Eagle (Regular Strike) | $28.00 | $30.00~$55.00 | $60.00~$160.00 | $225.00~$265.00 | $325.00~$610.00 | $625.00~$55,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Large Letters (Regular Strike) | $30.00~$32.00 | $34.00~$45.00 | $55.00~$135.00 | $200.00~$230.00 | $265.00~$590.00 | $600.00~$85,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858/7 Penny Strong (Regular Strike) | $42.00~$75.00 | $125.00~$300.00 | $310.00~$825.00 | $875.00~$1,150.00 | $1,600.00~$4,150.00 | $4,250.00~$75,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858/(7) Penny Weak (Regular Strike) | $45.00 | $55.00~$80.00 | $90.00~$285.00 | $325.00~$390.00 | $450.00~$625.00 | $675.00~$2,350.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Small Letters (Regular Strike) | $36.00~$38.00 | $42.00~$50.00 | $55.00~$150.00 | $200.00~$275.00 | $315.00~$635.00 | $650.00~$38,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle (Proof) | $5,500.00~$6,000.00 | $6,750.00~$9,500.00 | $11,000.00~$12,850.00 | $13,000.00~$13,250.00 | $13,500.00~$16,250.00 | $16,500.00~$250,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny DDO FS-104 S-5 (002.8) (Regular Strike) | $110.00 | $120.00~$150.00 | $165.00~$285.00 | $360.00~$400.00 | $425.00~$800.00 | $875.00~$3,350.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-2 (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $16,250.00~$26,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny DDO FS-101 Large Letters (Regular Strike) | - | $110.00~$150.00 | $165.00~$275.00 | $350.00~$400.00 | $500.00~$825.00 | $875.00~$7,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny RPD FS-301 S-11 (001.5) (Regular Strike) | - | $40.00~$80.00 | $90.00~$185.00 | $250.00~$285.00 | $300.00~$650.00 | $725.00~$4,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-2, CAM (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $32,500.00 | Shop |
| 1857 1C Obv. Clash w/ Half Dollar, FS-402, S-9 Flying Eagle (Regular Strike) | - | $65.00~$125.00 | $150.00~$260.00 | $285.00~$335.00 | $400.00~$825.00 | $900.00~$7,500.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-3 (Regular Strike) | $6,250.00 | $7,250.00~$9,750.00 | $11,500.00~$14,000.00 | $14,250.00~$14,600.00 | $14,750.00~$18,000.00 | $18,500.00~$85,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-3 (Proof) | - | $9,500.00 | $11,750.00~$13,500.00 | $13,750.00~$14,350.00 | $14,500.00~$17,250.00 | $17,500.00~$87,500.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny Flying Eagle, CAM (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $8,250.00~$95,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny Obv. Die Clash w/ $20, FS-403 (Regular Strike) | $215.00~$375.00 | $575.00~$750.00 | $900.00~$2,000.00 | $2,500.00~$7,000.00 | $8,000.00~$36,000.00 | - | Shop |
| 1858/7 Penny Overdate, FS-301, S-1 (Regular Strike) | $90.00 | $125.00~$310.00 | $325.00~$850.00 | $900.00~$1,100.00 | $1,650.00~$3,850.00 | $4,150.00~$90,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 1C Rev. Die Clash w/ Quarter, S-8 (Regular Strike) | - | $65.00~$160.00 | $185.00~$400.00 | $525.00~$600.00 | $675.00~$1,100.00 | $1,300.00~$10,500.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-4 (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $11,500.00~$35,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Small Letters, CAM (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $4,500.00~$50,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858/7 Penny Weak Overdate FS-302, S-7 (Regular Strike) | - | $130.00~$300.00 | $315.00~$650.00 | $700.00~$1,000.00 | $1,550.00~$3,600.00 | $3,750.00~$30,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny DDO FS-101, S-4 Flying Eagle (Regular Strike) | - | $42.00~$70.00 | $80.00~$140.00 | $200.00~$265.00 | $285.00~$575.00 | $625.00~$4,000.00 | Shop |
| 1858 Penny Large Letters, CAM (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $9,000.00~$60,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle, CAM (Proof) | - | - | - | - | - | $21,000.00~$28,000.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny DDO FS-102, Snow-15 (Regular Strike) | $70.00 | $80.00~$125.00 | $130.00~$215.00 | $275.00~$310.00 | $335.00~$675.00 | $725.00~$14,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-1 (Proof) | - | - | - | - | $16,750.00~$17,000.00 | $18,000.00~$55,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-5 (Proof) | - | - | $9,000.00 | - | - | $10,000.00~$76,500.00 | Shop |
| 1857 Penny DDO & RPD FS-103, S-10 Flying Eagle (Regular Strike) | $70.00 | $90.00~$165.00 | $170.00~$240.00 | $250.00~$310.00 | $350.00~$600.00 | $725.00~$3,000.00 | Shop |
| 1856 Penny Flying Eagle S-9 (Proof) | - | $9,000.00~$9,500.00 | $10,000.00~$11,750.00 | $12,000.00~$12,850.00 | $13,750.00~$16,350.00 | $16,750.00~$36,000.00 | Shop |